Challenges to Local Accountability
Constables are not facing a single dispute or a temporary policy disagreement. Across litigation, rulemaking, and administrative practice, the office is being narrowed in ways that raise serious questions about executive-branch encroachment on powers the General Assembly chose to grant.
Prosecution for Authorized Duties
Constable Steven Ahmad Wiggs was in a marked police cruiser, in uniform, performing an official law enforcement duty he is authorized by statute to perform. State police prosecuted him for it. In Philadelphia, every charge against Wiggs was dismissed, quashed, or resulted in a not-guilty verdict. A separate constable, Douglas Filson, was tried de novo on summary appeal and found Not Guilty in Montgomery County in November 2023.
A lights case in Perry County reached the Pennsylvania Superior Court. A 2-1 panel decision in February 2025 affirmed a conviction; the dissenting judge noted plainly that a legislature authorizing constables to direct traffic cannot deny them the emergency lights that allow motorists to recognize that authority. The full Superior Court has granted en banc reargument; the matter is pending and the panel decision is not final.
Administrative Obstruction
Beyond prosecution, state agencies erect barriers to constable operations. State Police have repeatedly denied constables Originating Agency Identifier (ORI) numbers — the federal identifier required to file criminal complaints electronically — citing supervision and accountability concerns the legislature's own 2014 LBFC report characterized as policy disputes rather than statutory disqualifications. Agencies issue policy documents arguing constables lack "police officer" status for operational purposes, ignoring a clear statutory pattern that places constables on functional parity with police officers for core law enforcement duties (75 Pa.C.S. §§ 102 and 3102; 18 Pa.C.S. § 501; 11 Pa.C.S. § 12005; 16 Pa.C.S. § 14340).
The Cost
Unwarranted charges cost constables thousands of dollars in legal defense and cost Pennsylvania taxpayers thousands more in prosecution costs — all for charges that are ultimately dismissed or result in acquittals. Beyond money, this pattern undermines voter trust. When state agencies prosecute constables for doing exactly what the legislature authorized, residents lose a layer of locally elected accountability they cannot easily replace.
The Pennsylvania Superior Court has ruled that executive agencies cannot diminish powers granted by statute or common law to independently elected officials. The pressure on the office continues through courts and rulemaking bodies rather than through the General Assembly — a venue where the substance of these disputes can be examined openly.
Read the full record on the Issues page